Cream Pies
Nonnie’s Cream Pies evolved over many years of trial and error before becoming the well loved, well reviewed pies that you’ve come to know and love at Farmer’s Markets and local fairs and festivals. We use our own special recipes, with the absolute freshest and top quality ingredients to create our pies. The result is what won First Place at an ESPN Baking Competition – a delicious, creamy and indulgent treat!
Our pies are available by the slice and in a 9″ family size. In addition to individual pies, we offer pie variety trays for larger gatherings by special order. Gluten free options are also available as a pre-order. Reach out to us here for more information.
Cream Pies
Banana Cream +
***Chocolate Cream
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cream +
***Coconut Cream
Egg Nog Cream*
Fruit Tart
Key Lime*
***Lemon Cream
Pecan Cream
Peppermint Bark Cream*
Pistachio Cream +
Pumpkin Cheesecake Cream* +
Rocky Road Cream
***Strawberry Cream +
*** Pre-Order Seasonal Pies + Other Variety of Pies
Variety Trays
Do you have a special event coming up? Need to bring a dessert to a party or gathering? Our Variety Trays are the perfect solution to parties, get-togethers and holidays! Pre-Order today and create a tray from your favorite flavors!
Made-to-Order Gluten Free Available!
